Зарегистрируйся на Last.fm или войди в свой профиль, чтобы оставить сообщение.
-
Ответы
-
-
Ответы
-
-
Ответы
-
Ответы
-
-
Bleeeeeeding
just came here wanting some new post punk / goth rock artists and got evanescence lol
Действия
Ответы
-
-
igorthe_killers
Look at the Top Tracks: Evanescence, MGMT, Zara Larsson.. What the hell people are doing with this tag????? 😳
Действия
Ответы
-
-
igorthe_killers
Why the hell people still tagging Evanescence as Gothic Rock? That's so.. better I shut up or a "Gothic teenage" will say "F*ck you dude, I'm really so Gothic" 😂😂😂
Действия
Ответы
-
Ответы
-
igorthe_killers
Yeah haha, every "pale skins" artists with black clothes for all are "goth" 😂
Действия
-
-
-
DeltaAirplane
To throw my hat into the ring I feel like Evanescence being tagged as goth rock is just not a good take and is a take made mostly by people who enjoy the look but don't delve much deeper beyond that. Goth rock isn't just rock by a band that looks goth its a genre in and of itself. Sure, post punk or 80's goth could cover some ground for what most fans of the genre would think of as being goth, it doesn't cover everything. There are a good amount of examples of what I consider to be goth artists who never touched post punk, and there are absolutely ways to make modern goth music without being heavily indebted to the 80's. Also not all post punk is goth. Evanescence shares more in common with other genres than with goth, and shouldn't be here. People who don't like Evanescence may be scared away from music they might like by music that they don't and Evanescence fans get a lot of music that doesn't sound like Evanescence what's the advantage for them being here
Действия
-
Ответы
-
Это сообщение недоступно.
-
Skunkysunky
They use gothic so broadly that gothic rock is a theme and not a genre to them :/ Gothic rock is the goth genre's back bone- It's distinctly post punk and not these industrial, metal, or vaguely gothic aesthetics. It's hyper specific to the sound and artists IE: The Cure, Siouxsie and the Banshees, Joy division etc etc. And Evanescence has to be the biggest slap in the face to goths. I hate to be the angry goth, but I am. Sorry :(
Действия
Ответы
-
Skunkysunky
ALSO LOOK UNDER "Goth" for the real gothic rock, dark wave, death rock, etc! Makes it 10 times easier to not be frustrated with this decision.
Действия
-
-
HuppumiesIsPest
Goths didn't have rock music. They just had rocks. It was not a great time.
Действия
-
LawLieTicp
evanescence, lil peep, nightwish and marilyn manson are the best gothic rock bands
Действия
-
Ответы
-
dead_but_funky
Эх, 2006, аська, девочки, которые ничего не понимают в музыке, но причисляют себя к готам, а ты им такой объясняешь, что хим/расмус/иванэсэнс - не готека... ностальгия...
Действия
Ответы
-
-
AntiFreeze1349
goth is when you wear black clothing. the more black clothing you wear, the gothier you are.
Действия
-
papermoon13
Evanescence did more for goth subculture than anybody else ever could, deal with it.
Действия
Ответы
Другие ответы-
Ответы
Другие ответы-
ZombieXBoy
First of all Strawhat, it is difficult to type in sarcasm and have everyone just get it and it is hard to tell if you were serious or not when many people think Evanescence is Goth music. You tried to make a funny but it did not land well, that is on you.
Действия
-
-
ViperaAmmodytes
Once again I am convinced that any threaded public discussion on the Internet sooner or later ends up being a spontaneous telling of the "How many forum users does it take to change a lightbulb" joke.
Действия
-
-
-
-
Ответы
-
dead_but_funky
Этому форсу сто лет в обед. Узнать бы, откуда изначально пошло. Журналюхи, наверное...
Действия
-
Ответы
-
-
-
-
-
Это сообщение недоступно.
-
-
TheArrow1987
Evane-scene doesn't belong here same with him and the 69 eyes. I can't stand the vocalist of Evane-scene but on that picture she has a nice ear. Bauhaus and The Sisters of Mercy are more correct under "gothic rock". They just sound completely different.
Действия
Ответы
-
Mar_Sexx_669
lmao love this shoutbox. yeah, you can debate whether Evanescence should be here or not. But you can't debate HIM. Period. Fun fact: The 69 Eyes band members said many times they let go of their full glam rock style and incorporated gothic rock in their music because they were influenced by HIM.
Действия
-
-
achmeazorg
I find it hilarious that Diamanda Galas is placed next to Evanescence here. Any teenage Evanescence fan trying out Diamanda would have nightmares for days. Hell, I've listened to black metal most of my life and even I think Diamanda Galas is disturbing.
Действия
-
-
Deathstalker068
are you kidding with me? evanescence gothic rock?, best joke of the century ha ha
Действия
-
Ms_Antrophia
Can we get fucking read of Evanescence in here? WHY ISN'T BAUHAUS IN THEIR PLACE? WHERE THE HECK IS SIOUXSIE?!
Действия
-
-
Это сообщение недоступно.
-
Riot-grrrl7
How's Evanescence considered gothic by so many people? They sound nothing like 80's gothic rock bands lol.
Действия
-
Silanis
"It's quite sad how fake became gothic rock and industrial tags here." weren't they always? Can't remember a time when the gothic and gothic rock tag here on lastfm didn't have these mallgoth bands. I'd even argue that the tags have slightly gotten better, since the 00s Hot Topic mallgoth fad finally ended.
Действия
-