加入 Last.fm 或登录后留言。
-
-
-
-
-
barosielle
"Real Indie Rock" only consists of the pnw DIY scene and the late 80's College Rock scene. What is known by "Post-Punk Revival" is nothing but Pop Rock with questionable real indie influence. When people try to argue that bands like Arctic Monkeys are not real indie, while saying that Arcade Fire are I can't help not to cringe because they are just as fake indie as Arctic Monkeys (plus the pretentiousness). Real indie sounds AUTHENTIC, INTENSE and somewhat AGGRESSIVE. Fake indie is weak, cash grab and a failed attempt to direct energy and emotion into music. Some examples of REAL INDIE ROCK are The Replacements, Pixies, Interpol (the only real indie band from the post-punk revival scene) and Modest Mouse. Some examples of FAKE INDIE are Arcade Fire, Arctic Monkeys and The Strokes INDIE BELONGS TO DIY NOT TO DANCE-PUNK, POP ROCK, CHAMBER POP OR ANY OTHER MAINSTREAM GENRE
操作
回复
-
回复
-
recursivechaos
your loss. i found this little essay extremely illuminating and would strongly encourage everyone who is interested in the history of popular music to read it.
操作
-
-
-
-
-
ZakiOwais
indie rocks history gotta be one of the bleakest examples of greed. It started out as something studios wouldn't promote. It was genuine and artists had the most control. Then it started being recognized as a genre. Then studio execs thought "hey we can release albums under the pretense that we are not interfering". It's like if now punk rock was made that sounds exactly like blackflag or d.kennedys, but there was a corporate exec giving orders. It's just bleak and void of art.
操作
-
-
回复
-
回复
-
回复
-
-
-
technomaster45
indie rock went from no label/small label bands to just sounding like they aren't signed onto the biggest label on earth
操作
-
回复
-
回复
-
-
asocialfairy
I always get tripped up on whether or not to distinguish alt rock and indie rock (especially in the context of the 1980s/early 90s). For instance, they call Sonic Youth one of the first indie bands but they were also an (early) alt rock band in the mid-late 1980s...
操作
回复
-
meikaelaeinen
For me, something like R.E.M. is alternative rock, and Franz Ferdinand is indie. I'm not very knowledgeable about rock genres though...
操作
-
-
Biatorisuu
pessoal falando do franz e arctic monkeys sendo que são da Dominó Records... uma gravadora independente
操作
-
回复
-
-
largeslavicman
real indie rock only consists of 90s post-hardcore adjacent alt rock a la Built to Spill, Modest Mouse, Archers of Loaf, and Dismemberment plan. What is known as "indie rock" is nothing but pop rock with a slight post-punk or alt rock slant.
操作
回复
-
Sheva271102
And even Modest Mouse can't be considered as an actual indie rock band now since they are signed to a major label, Epic Records.
操作
回复
-
largeslavicman
same goes for Built to Spill. from Perfect onwards they were signed to Warner Bros. Archers of Loaf also released one album (conveniently their worst) on Elektra records. the only band I listed that was actually indie rock is DIsmemberment Plan, who DID get signed to a major label, but never released anything on it.
操作
-
-
-
-
-
回复
-
-
davesantos
The Killers, Franz Ferdinand and Strokes are cool bands, but to call them indie is just wrong... I blame record labels.
操作
回复
-
-
nfopuhfxir
Can anyone tell me any indie rock bands that aren’t boring? (And if you say the strokes I will find you and I will kill you)
操作
回复
-
-
largeslavicman
built to spill, (early) modest mouse, archers of loaf, engine down, dismemberment plan.
操作
-
回复
-
-
回复
-
MegaDave89
I must say, i like Indie Rock, i admit it were hard to begin with. Damn what a musical genre to discover. I do like Arctic Monkeys best and i likes Neutral Milk Hotel.
操作
-
-
此留言无法显示。
回复
-
-
回复
-
此留言无法显示。
-
-
-
-
此留言无法显示。
-
此留言无法显示。
-
El_Salvador7
Why are there always so many extremely sour people in these genre shoutboxes on last.fm?
操作
回复
-
-
此留言无法显示。
回复
-
-
-
-
-
IgIanBarrett
Все указанные группы в топ - это ненастоящий инди рок. Инди на то и инди, что должен быть оригинальным и уникальным, а в AM и The Killers чего точно нет, так это оригинальности.
操作
回复
-
seeemilieplaysf
KODALINE rocks it in this live performance of Love Will Set You Free! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xz6GRmDBV18&feature=youtu.be
操作